Challenging an ongoing investigation by the SEC is a daunting task, particularly for those identified as subjects of the investigation. Two recent holdings, one by the Third Circuit in Gentile v. Sec. & Exch. Comm’n, 2020 WL 5416297 (3d Cir. Sept. 10, 2020) and the other by the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey in Sec. & Exch. Comm’n v. Gentile, 16-cv-01619-BRM-JAD (Order Sept. 29, 2020), both of which involved the same parties, offer some clarification on when and how best to mount such a challenge. The Third Circuit’s opinion makes clear that the SEC’s ability to investigate is one of the “rare circumstances” in which an agency’s action is exempt from the waiver of sovereign immunity that might otherwise apply under the Administrative Procedure Act and, as a result, is not subject to judicial review. By contrast, the district court’s opinion reinforces that, once an investigation results in an enforcement action in federal court, the SEC is subject to the court’s rules and review as any other litigant. Taken together, these opinions present both practitioners and those in the securities industry with useful guidance in when and how to challenge the SEC.
In an era where technology is revolutionizing the practice of law, it is crucial for practitioners t...
Revocable living trusts are the cornerstone of modern estate planning, yet many attorneys new to the...
Millions of times per year, liability insurers hire panel counsel to defend policyholders in third p...
This program examines the scope, jurisdiction, and exceptions to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), ...
Attendees will learn how to effectively cross-examine witnesses at trial. The conventional wis...
The practice of law places legal professionals under extraordinary and often chronic stress, making ...
This program examines the legal standards and factors courts throughout the United States apply when...
As the legal landscape evolves, understanding both the recurring and emerging risks and challenges t...
Conducting an internal investigation that is incisive, effective and legally compliant is tough enou...
Unrecorded time, vague entries, and end-of-month write-offs cost firms significant revenue. This pra...